Legal Writers for Hire Legal drafting service

Response to a Motion for Summary Judgment: Opposition Drafting Service

How to draft a response to motion for summary judgment under FRCP Rule 56: the Celotex standard, local-rule deadlines, and required components.

Written and reviewed by the Legal Writers for Hire editorial team 16 min read Updated November 22, 2026
Response to Motion for Summary Judgment guide cover: the title and the Legal Writers for Hire wordmark

Overview

  • A response to motion for summary judgment is a formal written opposition filed by the non-moving party under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure Rule 56 or a state court equivalent, contesting the movant's claim that no genuine dispute of material fact exists and that judgment is warranted as a matter of law.
  • The legal standard governing evaluation of a response to motion for summary judgment requires the non-moving party to present specific, admissible evidence showing a genuine dispute of material fact that a reasonable jury could resolve in its favor, as established in Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317 (1986).
  • A response to motion for summary judgment in federal court must be filed within 21 days of the motion under FRCP Rule 56(c)(1), though local rules in districts such as the Southern District of New York or the Northern District of California may impose shorter or different deadlines.
  • The required components of a response to motion for summary judgment include a memorandum of law, a counter-statement of genuine disputes responding paragraph by paragraph to the movant's Rule 56.1 statement, supporting affidavits or declarations, and authenticated exhibits drawn from the admissible record.
  • A response to motion for summary judgment that relies on conclusory statements, unauthenticated exhibits, or inadmissible hearsay risks being stricken or disregarded, leaving the court to treat the underlying motion as unopposed and potentially granting judgment against the non-moving party.

What Is a Response to Motion for Summary Judgment?

A response to motion for summary judgment is the non-moving party's formal written opposition, filed under FRCP Rule 56 or a state court equivalent, contesting the movant's position that no genuine dispute of material fact exists and that the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. The document consists of a memorandum of law, a counter-statement of disputed facts, and evidentiary attachments drawn from the record. It is not a complaint or new pleading; it is a targeted rebuttal designed to show the court that a trial is necessary.

The response differs from related procedural filings in function and timing. A cross-motion for summary judgment asks the court to grant judgment in favor of the respondent, while a response alone only seeks to defeat the movant's motion. A reply brief is the movant's answer to the opposition, and a surreply is an additional filing permitted only by leave of court in most districts. The responding party in federal court is typically the non-moving party, whether a plaintiff defending against a defendant's motion or a defendant opposing a plaintiff's motion.

What Are the Legal Standards a Court Applies When Evaluating a Response to Motion for Summary Judgment?

Courts evaluating a response to motion for summary judgment apply the "genuine dispute of material fact" standard under FRCP Rule 56(a), asking whether the non-moving party's evidence is sufficient for a reasonable jury to return a verdict in its favor. A fact is "material" only when it could affect the outcome under governing substantive law, and a dispute is "genuine" only when the competing evidence goes beyond speculation or mere assertion. Courts view all evidence in the light most favorable to the non-moving party at this stage.

The burden-shifting framework in summary judgment practice flows from three landmark Supreme Court decisions. In Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317 (1986), the Court held that the movant may meet its initial burden by showing an absence of evidence supporting the non-movant's case, not merely by producing its own affirmative proof. Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242 (1986), established that the "reasonable jury" test governs the sufficiency inquiry, and Matsushita Electric Industrial Co. v. Zenith Radio Corp., 475 U.S. 574 (1986), clarified that implausible inferences do not create a genuine dispute even when some evidence exists.

How Does a Party File a Response to Motion for Summary Judgment in Federal Court?

Flow chart of five steps: review the motion, identify contentions, gather evidence, draft the memorandum and counter-statement, and submit through CM/ECF.
The sequence for filing a response to motion for summary judgment in federal court, from reviewing the motion to CM/ECF submission.

To file a response to motion for summary judgment in federal court, the non-moving party follows a sequential process: reviewing the motion and supporting brief, identifying the factual and legal contentions to rebut, gathering opposing evidence from the record, drafting the memorandum of law and counter-statement, and submitting all documents through the court's CM/ECF electronic filing system. Each step in that sequence must be completed before the deadline, because federal courts rarely grant late extensions without a demonstrated reason tied to good cause or excusable neglect under FRCP Rule 6(b).

The table below shows how key filing requirements compare across common federal and state procedural frameworks.

JurisdictionDefault Response DeadlineKey Rule
Federal (FRCP)21 days after motion is servedFRCP Rule 56(c)(1)
California14 days before hearing dateCCP § 437c(b)(2)
New YorkAs set by court order or 7 days before return dateCPLR § 3212(b)
Texas7 days before hearingTex. R. Civ. P. 166a(c)

Required accompanying documents in federal court include a response to the movant's statement of undisputed material facts under the applicable local rule (such as Local Rule 56.1 in the Southern District of New York), a declaration or affidavit signed under penalty of perjury, and authenticated exhibits such as deposition transcripts, interrogatory answers, and documentary evidence (FRCP Rule 56(c)(4)).

What Must Be Included in a Response to Motion for Summary Judgment?

Checklist showing introduction, counter-statement, argument section, conclusion, deposition excerpts, verified interrogatory answers, and affidavits on personal knowledge.
Checklist of the structural parts and evidence a response to motion for summary judgment must contain.

A response to motion for summary judgment must contain four structural components: an introduction stating the case posture and the relief sought, a counter-statement of genuine disputes addressing each paragraph of the movant's Rule 56.1 statement with a specific record citation, an argument section organized by legal issue with citations to statutes and case law, and a conclusion requesting that the court deny the motion. Omitting the counter-statement or leaving paragraphs admitted by default is one of the most common and consequential drafting errors, because courts in jurisdictions such as the Southern District of New York treat uncontroverted paragraphs as admitted (Local Rule 56.1(c)).

Supporting evidentiary materials are integral to the response, not optional attachments. Deposition excerpts must be attached as exhibits with the relevant pages highlighted; interrogatory answers must be verified; affidavits and declarations must be made on personal knowledge and set out facts that would be admissible at trial under FRCP Rule 56(c)(4). Expert declarations used to controvert the movant's expert must satisfy the requirements of Federal Rule of Evidence 702 and, where applicable, the standard set by Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (1993).

How Do You Argue Against a Motion for Summary Judgment Effectively?

To argue against a motion for summary judgment effectively, the non-moving party must identify specific, competing evidence that directly contradicts each material fact the movant claims is undisputed, juxtaposing the movant's deposition testimony, documents, or expert opinions against the respondent's own record evidence to show the conflict a jury must resolve. Effective opposition does not simply deny the movant's facts in the abstract; it points to named exhibits, specific pages, and concrete facts that a reasonable juror could credit over the movant's version.

Legal argument strategies extend beyond factual disputes. The respondent can challenge the movant's legal theory by arguing that the governing substantive standard requires more than the movant's evidence demonstrates, assert affirmative defenses supported by record evidence, or invoke FRCP Rule 56(d) to request that the court defer ruling or deny the motion because essential facts are unavailable pending discovery. Courts have recognized that a Rule 56(d) affidavit must identify the specific facts sought, explain why they cannot yet be presented, and show that the expected discovery is likely to generate a genuine dispute. See Burlington N. Santa Fe R.R. Co. v. Assiniboine & Sioux Tribes of Fort Peck Reservation, 323 F.3d 767 (9th Cir. 2003).

What Are the Deadlines and Local Rules That Govern a Response to Motion for Summary Judgment?

Deadlines governing a response to motion for summary judgment vary significantly across jurisdictions, as the comparison table under the filing section shows, and local rules impose additional requirements beyond the default periods set by FRCP Rule 56(c)(1) and state equivalents. The Northern District of California's Civil Local Rule 7-3, for example, requires opposition briefs within 14 days of service of the motion, a tighter window than the federal default. Practitioners must check the district's local rules, the assigned judge's standing orders, and any scheduling order entered under FRCP Rule 16 before calculating a deadline.

To request an extension, the non-moving party must file a motion showing good cause before the deadline expires; after the deadline, the party must demonstrate excusable neglect under FRCP Rule 6(b)(1)(B), a standard that considers the reason for the delay, whether the opposing party would be prejudiced, and whether the moving party acted in good faith. Pioneer Inv. Servs. Co. v. Brunswick Assocs. Ltd. P'ship, 507 U.S. 380 (1993), established the multi-factor excusable neglect test still applied in federal courts. Failing to respond at all carries the risk that the court will treat the summary judgment motion as conceded and enter judgment without reaching the merits, though courts retain discretion to review the record independently.

Why Can a Response to Motion for Summary Judgment Be Denied or Stricken?

A response to motion for summary judgment can be stricken on procedural grounds when the filing exceeds the page or word limits set by local rules (for example, 25 pages under S.D.N.Y. Local Rule 11.1), misses the filing deadline, fails to comply with font or margin requirements, or attaches unauthenticated exhibits that do not satisfy FRCP Rule 56(c)(2). Courts in the Ninth Circuit have stricken entire opposition papers for failure to comply with the district's standing order on electronic exhibit formatting, leaving the movant's facts undisputed.

Substantive insufficiency presents a separate ground for disregard. Courts disregard counter-statements that contain only conclusory denials without a specific record citation, and they exclude declarations based on information and belief rather than personal knowledge. Hearsay not falling within a recognized exception under the Federal Rules of Evidence is inadmissible at summary judgment and cannot create a genuine dispute. Scott v. Harris, 550 U.S. 372 (2007), confirmed that a court need not credit a party's version of events when it is blatantly contradicted by objective record evidence such as a video recording. Courts respond to defective filings by ordering supplemental briefing, granting leave to cure within a fixed period, or proceeding to grant summary judgment on the merits.

How Does a Response to Motion for Summary Judgment Differ From a Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment?

Comparison graphic with two cards contrasting a pure response, which only defeats the motion, and a cross-motion, which seeks judgment for the respondent.
How a response to motion for summary judgment differs from a cross-motion in purpose, relief sought and briefing.

A cross-motion for summary judgment is a separate affirmative motion filed by the responding party simultaneously with their opposition brief, asking the court to grant judgment in the respondent's favor on the same claims or issues raised by the original motion. The cross-motion asserts that the respondent, not the original movant, is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. It requires its own supporting memorandum, its own statement of undisputed facts, and its own evidentiary record distinct from the opposition materials.

The structural and strategic differences between a pure response and a cross-motion are significant. A response to motion for summary judgment contests the movant's entitlement to judgment without affirmatively seeking any relief; a cross-motion shifts the court's analysis to whether the respondent deserves judgment instead. Procedurally, cross-motions trigger a separate briefing schedule: the original movant typically files a combined reply to the opposition and opposition to the cross-motion, followed by the cross-movant's reply. Courts may hold consolidated hearings and retain authority under FRCP Rule 56(g) to grant partial summary judgment on discrete claims, issues, or defenses even when full judgment is not warranted.

Who Bears the Burden of Proof in Responding to a Motion for Summary Judgment?

Parties diagram showing the movant's showing to the court, the burden shifting to the non-moving party, and the non-movant unable to rest on pleadings.
Burden-shifting in a response to motion for summary judgment: the movant shows no dispute, then the non-movant must present evidence.

The burden in summary judgment practice begins with the movant, who must demonstrate the absence of a genuine dispute of material fact; once the movant makes that showing, the burden shifts to the non-moving party to present specific, admissible evidence creating a triable issue. This burden-shifting sequence, established in Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317 (1986), means the non-moving party cannot simply rest on the pleadings once the movant has carried its initial burden. The non-movant must point to the record, not merely repeat allegations.

Direct and circumstantial evidence carry equal weight at summary judgment, and the non-moving party may rely on either to satisfy its responsive burden. The burden analysis changes when the case involves an affirmative defense; there, the non-moving party may bear the ultimate burden of persuasion at trial and must therefore produce enough evidence at the summary judgment stage to permit a reasonable jury to find in its favor on each element of that defense. Where the non-movant bears the burden of proof at trial, the movant can satisfy its initial burden merely by pointing to the absence of evidence on a required element, as Celotex made clear.

Questions About Response to Motion for Summary Judgment

How long does a response to a motion for summary judgment need to be?

The length of a response to motion for summary judgment is controlled by local rules, not FRCP Rule 56 itself. For example, the Southern District of New York caps opposition memoranda at 25 pages under Local Rule 7.1(c), while the Northern District of California limits them to 25 pages under Civil Local Rule 7-4(b).

Can a party file a response to motion for summary judgment without a lawyer?

Yes, a pro se party may file a response to motion for summary judgment without a lawyer, but the same procedural rules apply regardless of representation status. The non-moving party must still submit admissible evidence, comply with local formatting rules, and meet the filing deadline.

What happens if no response to a motion for summary judgment is filed?

Failure to file a response to motion for summary judgment can result in the court treating the motion as unopposed and granting it without a full merits analysis. Some courts, such as those following the Eastern District of Virginia's procedures, explicitly warn in their local rules that failure to respond constitutes consent to granting the motion.

Does filing a response to a motion for summary judgment guarantee a trial?

No, filing a response to motion for summary judgment does not guarantee a trial; the court still decides whether the evidence creates a genuine dispute that only a jury can resolve. The response succeeds when it persuades the court that at least one material fact is genuinely contested.

Is oral argument required when opposing a motion for summary judgment?

No, oral argument on a response to motion for summary judgment is not automatically required in federal court; the court may decide the motion on the papers alone under FRCP Rule 78(b). A party seeking oral argument must request it in accordance with the local rules of the district, and the court retains discretion to grant or deny that request.

Legal Writers for Hire drafts fully supported responses to motions for summary judgment for clients in all states and all federal courts, with free revisions and a written quote before you pay. Contact the team to request a quote for your opposition brief; the team responds within minutes.