Legal Writers for Hire Legal drafting service

Motion for Rehearing or Reconsideration on Appeal: Drafting Service

A motion for rehearing asks the same court to fix a legal or factual error. Covers FRAP Rule 40, the 14-day deadline, and certiorari tolling.

Written and reviewed by the Legal Writers for Hire editorial team 16 min read Updated November 22, 2026
Motion for Rehearing guide cover: the title and the Legal Writers for Hire wordmark

Overview

  • A motion for rehearing is a post-ruling request filed with the same court that issued the decision, asking that court to correct a legal error, overlooked authority, or factual mistake before the case proceeds to a higher tribunal.
  • Federal appellate courts govern rehearing under Fed. R. App. P. 40, which sets a 14-day deadline from entry of judgment for a party to file a petition for panel rehearing in a civil case.
  • A motion for rehearing differs from a direct appeal in that it targets the issuing court rather than a superior court, and it differs from a motion for reconsideration in that rehearing is primarily an appellate remedy while reconsideration applies at the trial court level.
  • Filing a motion for rehearing under FRAP Rule 40 tolls the time to file a petition for certiorari in the U.S. Supreme Court, making it a strategically significant step in federal litigation (28 U.S.C. § 2101(c)).
  • A denied motion for rehearing triggers the final appellate deadline, so parties must track that denial date with the same precision they applied to the original judgment.

What Is a Motion for Rehearing?

A motion for rehearing is a formal post-ruling request submitted to the court that issued the decision, asking that court to reconsider its ruling on the ground that the panel overlooked controlling authority, made a factual error, or applied the wrong legal standard. At the federal appellate level, the motion is governed by Fed. R. App. P. 40, which authorizes a party to petition for panel rehearing by identifying the specific point of law or fact the court misapprehended. State equivalents include Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.330, California Rule of Court 8.268, and Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 49, each with its own scope and deadline.

Rehearing, rehearing en banc, and reconsideration are three distinct procedural vehicles. Panel rehearing under FRAP Rule 40 asks the original three-judge panel to correct its own decision. Rehearing en banc under FRAP Rule 35 asks the full circuit court to reconsider a panel decision that conflicts with circuit precedent or presents a question of exceptional importance. Reconsideration is a trial court remedy, available under Fed. R. Civ. P. 59(e) or 60(b), that challenges a district court order rather than an appellate ruling. All three apply to different rulings: panel rehearing targets appellate decisions, en banc review targets circuit-wide precedent, and reconsideration targets final judgments and interlocutory orders at the trial level.

How Does a Motion for Rehearing Work in Court?

Flow chart of six steps for a motion for rehearing, from filing and serving the petition to the court's decision and the certiorari clock restarting.
A motion for rehearing is filed, served, and decided on the written petition, and denial restarts the certiorari clock.

A motion for rehearing follows a defined procedural sequence that begins with the party filing a written petition within the applicable deadline, served on all opposing counsel, and submitted to the clerk of the appellate court that issued the challenged decision. The opposing party receives no automatic right to respond unless the court orders a response (FRAP Rule 40(a)(3)); the court may deny the petition without requesting a reply. Oral argument on a motion for rehearing is rarely granted; most circuits and state appellate courts decide the petition on the written submission alone.

The court evaluates the motion by examining whether the original decision overlooked a point of law or fact that, had it been considered, would have altered the outcome. Courts do not use rehearing as an opportunity to hear new arguments or reweigh evidence already presented. Filing a timely motion for rehearing under FRAP Rule 40 tolls the 90-day period to petition the U.S. Supreme Court for certiorari under 28 U.S.C. § 2101(c), so the certiorari clock restarts from the date the rehearing petition is denied rather than from the date of the original appellate judgment.

What Are the Grounds for Filing a Motion for Rehearing?

Checklist graphic listing four accepted grounds for a motion for rehearing and three impermissible grounds courts reject.
A motion for rehearing must rest on accepted grounds such as overlooked authority, not restated arguments.

Accepted grounds for a motion for rehearing cluster around three recognized categories: the court overlooked or misapplied controlling authority, the court made a factual finding that the record does not support, or newly discovered evidence emerged that was unavailable at the time of the original briefing and argument. Courts in federal circuits treat the first category as the strongest basis because it requires only a comparison of the panel's reasoning to existing precedent without demanding credibility determinations.

  1. Overlooked or misapplied controlling authority (e.g., the panel failed to apply a binding circuit precedent directly on point)
  2. Factual error in the court's findings (e.g., the opinion mischaracterized the trial record)
  3. Newly discovered evidence that could not have been obtained through reasonable diligence before the original argument
  4. Intervening change in controlling law after the original briefing closed

Impermissible grounds include restating arguments the party already made and lost, disagreeing with the court's weighing of the evidence, or introducing points that were waived at the trial level. In Browder v. Director, Dep't of Corrections of Illinois, 434 U.S. 257 (1978), the Supreme Court confirmed that a motion for rehearing that merely re-argues the merits does not toll appellate deadlines and carries no procedural weight as a substantive post-judgment remedy.

What Are the Deadlines and Timing Requirements for a Motion for Rehearing?

Comparison cards showing motion for rehearing deadlines and extension options under FRAP Rule 40 and Florida, California, and Texas rules.
Motion for rehearing deadlines range from 14 days under FRAP Rule 40 to 15 days in Florida, California, and Texas.

FRAP Rule 40(a)(1) sets a 14-day deadline from entry of the court of appeals' judgment for a party to file a petition for panel rehearing in a civil case; the deadline extends to 45 days when the United States or its agency is a party. State courts diverge significantly from that federal baseline. Florida Rule 9.330 requires the motion within 15 days of the decision. California Rule 8.268 sets a 15-day window in the Court of Appeal. Texas Rule 49.1 allows 15 days from the date of judgment in the courts of appeals, with a possible extension to 60 days for en banc reconsideration under Rule 49.7.

Court or RuleDeadlineExtension Available
FRAP Rule 40 (civil, private party)14 days from judgmentCourt order required
FRAP Rule 40 (U.S. as party)45 days from judgmentCourt order required
Florida Rule 9.33015 days from decisionCourt discretion
California Rule 8.26815 days from filing of decisionCourt discretion
Texas Rule 49.115 days from judgmentUp to 60 days for en banc (Rule 49.7)

Deadline calculation follows FRAP Rule 26, which excludes intermediate Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays when the period is less than 11 days under older counting rules, but current FRAP Rule 26(a)(1) counts every day including weekends for periods of 14 days or more, with the period ending at 11:59 p.m. on the final day. Missing the deadline forfeits the right to rehearing, strips the motion of tolling effect on certiorari deadlines, and may accelerate the finality of the appellate judgment.

How Do You Write and Format a Motion for Rehearing?

Checklist of six parts and format requirements for drafting a motion for rehearing, including caption, argument, prayer for relief, and word limit.
A motion for rehearing needs a caption, introduction, standard of review, argument, and prayer for relief within word limits.

To write a motion for rehearing, structure the document with a caption identifying the court, case number, and parties; a concise introduction stating the precise point the court overlooked; a standard of review section acknowledging the applicable rule; an argument section organized around the overlooked authority or factual error; and a prayer for relief specifying whether the party seeks a corrected opinion, a new briefing order, or oral argument. The argument must cite the specific page and line of the opinion where the error occurs and pair it with the controlling authority the court failed to apply.

FRAP Rule 40(b) limits a petition for panel rehearing to 3,900 words when produced by a computer, or 15 pages when handwritten or typewritten, absent a court order permitting more. State limits vary: California Rule 8.268(b)(1) caps the motion at 8,400 words or 25 pages in a Court of Appeal. The strategic goal of the argument section is to frame the motion as a correction of an objective legal mistake rather than an expression of disagreement with the outcome. Phrases that position the motion as a re-argument of the merits invite summary denial, while precise citations to overlooked binding precedent signal that the motion serves the legitimate purpose the rule authorizes.

What Is the Difference Between a Motion for Rehearing and a Motion for Reconsideration?

A motion for rehearing applies at the appellate court level and asks the panel or full court that decided the appeal to revisit its own decision before the case becomes final. A motion for reconsideration applies at the trial court level and challenges a district court's order or judgment under Fed. R. Civ. P. 59(e) (filed within 28 days of judgment) or Rule 60(b) (filed within a reasonable time, up to one year for certain grounds). The two motions operate in different courts, against different types of rulings, and under different standards of review.

Some jurisdictions use the terms interchangeably, which creates confusion for practitioners working across state lines. Florida, for instance, labels the trial-level remedy a "motion for rehearing" under Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.530, while federal practice reserves "rehearing" for appellate proceedings and uses "reconsideration" for the district court context. Texas employs "motion for rehearing" at the appellate level under Rule 49 and "motion for new trial" at the district court level under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 329b. Local rules govern the distinction absolutely, so the practitioner must consult the specific court's rules before selecting the label.

When Should an Attorney File a Motion for Rehearing Instead of Proceeding Directly to Appeal?

Filing a motion for rehearing is strategically preferable when the appellate decision contains a clear, correctable legal error that the same court can fix without requiring intervention from a higher tribunal, particularly when fixing the error at the intermediate appellate level saves significant time and cost. The motion tolls certiorari deadlines under 28 U.S.C. § 2101(c) and preserves the opportunity to raise the corrected ruling on further review. Courts accept issue preservation through the rehearing process, so a party that spots an error in the opinion not addressed by the original briefs benefits from raising it in a timely rehearing petition before proceeding higher.

Skipping rehearing and filing directly for appeal or certiorari is preferable when the intermediate court's error is entrenched in circuit or state precedent that only a higher court can reverse, or when the deadline pressure on the certiorari petition makes an intermediate filing impractical. The risk of omitting rehearing is real: several circuits treat issues raised for the first time in a certiorari petition as unpreserved when no rehearing petition gave the lower court a chance to correct the alleged error. The practitioner must weigh the tolling benefit against the cost of an additional round of briefing.

What Happens After a Motion for Rehearing Is Denied?

Denial of a motion for rehearing triggers the restart of the certiorari clock under 28 U.S.C. § 2101(c), giving the losing party 90 days from the date of denial to petition the U.S. Supreme Court for review. At the state level, denial of a motion for rehearing at the intermediate appellate court similarly triggers the deadline to petition the state supreme court for discretionary review. The party's options at that stage are to file a petition for certiorari or discretionary review, pursue an extraordinary writ if one applies to the procedural posture, or accept the judgment as final.

The denial itself carries limited precedential weight and does not constitute an independent ruling on the merits. Courts have held that a denial of rehearing is not equivalent to a ruling on a new legal theory, so it does not create an independent ground for further review beyond what the original opinion decided. The question of whether a denied motion for rehearing can support an ineffective assistance of counsel claim is jurisdiction-specific; most courts hold that the failure to file a motion for rehearing, standing alone, does not constitute deficient performance under Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668 (1984), unless the omission caused the loss of a meritorious right to further review.

Which Courts and Jurisdictions Have Specific Rules Governing Motions for Rehearing?

Federal circuit courts operate under FRAP Rules 35 and 40, with individual circuit rules adding requirements specific to each court. The U.S. Supreme Court governs petitions for rehearing under Supreme Court Rule 44, which requires the petition to be filed within 25 days of the order sought to be reheard and limits the document to 10 pages. The Ninth Circuit's Local Rule 35-3 restricts en banc requests to cases involving a conflict with published circuit precedent or a question of exceptional importance, tracking the FRAP Rule 35 standard precisely.

Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.330 is mandatory before seeking discretionary jurisdiction in the Florida Supreme Court for most categories of decisions, making rehearing a prerequisite rather than an optional step in that state. California Rule of Court 8.268 makes rehearing discretionary and requires the motion to identify the specific error in the opinion. Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 49 governs both panel rehearing (Rule 49.1) and en banc reconsideration (Rule 49.7), and the Texas Supreme Court imposes its own requirements under Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 64 for motions directed to that court. Practitioners moving across jurisdictions must map each court's specific rule because the deadlines, word limits, and mandatory versus discretionary status vary enough to change the strategic calculus at every level.

Questions About Motion for Rehearing

Does filing a motion for rehearing automatically extend the time to appeal?

Yes, but only when the motion is timely and authorized by the applicable rule. A timely motion for rehearing under FRAP Rule 40 tolls the period to petition for certiorari under 28 U.S.C. § 2101(c), so the 90-day certiorari period runs from the date of denial rather than from the original judgment date.

Is a response from the opposing party required after a motion for rehearing is filed?

No, an opposing party response is not automatically required. Under FRAP Rule 40(a)(3), the court of appeals may deny a petition for panel rehearing without requesting a response from the opposing side.

Can a motion for rehearing raise new legal arguments not presented in the original briefs?

No, a motion for rehearing cannot introduce new legal theories that the party did not present before the original ruling. The motion is limited to pointing out matters the court overlooked or misapplied from the existing record and briefing.

What word or page limit applies to a motion for rehearing in federal appellate court?

FRAP Rule 40(b) limits a petition for panel rehearing to 3,900 words when produced by computer, or 15 pages when typewritten. Courts may set different limits by order, so the practitioner must check the specific circuit's local rules before filing.

Does the U.S. Supreme Court have its own motion for rehearing procedure?

Yes, the Supreme Court governs petitions for rehearing under Supreme Court Rule 44, which sets a 25-day deadline from the entry of the order and limits the petition to 10 pages. The Court grants rehearing only under extraordinary circumstances, making denial the near-universal outcome.

Is a motion for rehearing required before filing a petition for certiorari?

No, a motion for rehearing at the federal appellate level is not a mandatory prerequisite to filing a certiorari petition. However, some state supreme courts, including Florida's, require a motion for rehearing at the intermediate appellate court before the high court will accept discretionary jurisdiction.

Legal Writers for Hire drafts motions for rehearing, en banc petitions, and supporting appellate documents for clients in all states and federal courts, with free revisions and a flat fee quoted before you pay. Contact the team to request a quote and get a response within minutes.